Ok, I may have a tiny obsession with Retro Butterick patterns. Being the stupid shape I am, and not the smallest at that (41, 32, 45 measurements here. That 13 inch waist-to-hip difference causes about as much hassle as you'd expect), it's an awful lot easier using modern reproductions than the originals.
After the sleepless delirium of The 24 Hour Day Dress, I thought it would be a laugh to make myself a 1950's dress. One that didn't have quite such strict time constraints. I had a few yards of green taffeta left over from an 18th century dress I made a while back and am yet to post, and wanted to use it up anyway, so why not? Butterick's B6055 caught my eye as one of the most stereotypically retro dress patterns out there. The second suggested fabric was taffeta, and the artwork almost perfectly matched the colour of my fabric. It was simply meant to be!
Everyone hears of the plight of taffeta. Somehow I had managed to machine sew a 1780's robe a l'anglaise a la polonaise in tafftea with somewhere over 100 5mm pleats without a hitch. Really, it would have done me good to mess up more using such a finicky fabric for the first time. I imagined it would be just as straight-forward as the last time. Oh boy was I wrong.
To be fair, almost everything that went wrong was entirely my fault. In a blur of excitement, I started the dress as soon as I'd gathered all the notions for it.
See, here's another problem I have. I get cocky. "Oh yeah, it looks easy enough. I don't need to make a toile", I think to myself. Boy oh boy was I wrong. I made the bodice and skirt, not a problem. I had taken note that, as always, I needed to bring in the waist quite a bit. I stitched the two pieces together, and attempted sort out the waist. It would have been fine, if it weren't for my freaking massive hips. I simply could not manage to get the dress to accommodate those stupid thirteen inches in such little space. In the end, I ended up going over it so many times that I all but destroyed the taffeta, and the dress in the process. Good riddance, I thought at this point.
I did truly want this dress though, so I ordered more fabric; a simple cheap polycotton this time. I hadn't added the cost for fabrics to my budget, as this was more of a scraps project than anything else, so didn't really have the money for historical accuracy.
Looking back on my mistakes, I decided to make some alterations. I did away with the pockets and completely disregarded the skirt pattern, going for the good old faithful circle skirt instead. I lengthened the sleeves a bit to hide a little more of my arms, and added cuffs mostly just because I had nothing better to do. I've got to say, getting the fit on the bodice is one of my proudest moments. It really says something though when there's a zip right down the side and you still struggle to get the waist over your bust. "Form-fitting" is what I call it.
![]() |
| The end result of my antics, and far too many photo filters |
![]() |
| The original pattern photo |
In the end, I had myself a dress completely transformed! The original pattern was loose-fitting, and looked most suitable for the staff of an American diner more than anything else. I felt more at home in some classy jazz lounge with my frock and a pair of white gloves. To finish it all off, I found the perfect little original 50s self-cover belt buckle that I nabbed for under a fiver including postage.
Moral of the story: don't skip toiles, kids. Don't get cocky.











